Issue Gotham Knights 16  
Subtitle Matatoa part one
B&W backup story: The Bat No More by Alan Grant (w) and Enrique Breccia (a)
Date June 2001
Writer(s) Devin Grayson
Artist(s) Roger Robinson, John Floyd
storyline Bruce Wayne dreamed of his parents, Dick's parents, and Jason. On patrol that night, Batman pursued a man who'd shot up a bar. Upon capturing him, the man (who called himself Matatoa)  told Batman he was an immortal that fed on the souls of his kills, gaining their qualities - he had to kill to stay alive. Nightwing showed up as he was offering to kill Batman so that he could guard Gotham City forever.